Confused about Media Servers under $500? Do you need one? Start Here!

There is a lot to understand when it comes to getting content (video, pictures, music, etc.) over the Internet. Streaming, media servers, buffering, paid and free and much more. Basically there are two ways to get content.

Streaming

When you stream content, the movie is sitting on a server somewhere besides your house, and is constantly sent (streamed) to your home so you can watch it. Netfix, vimeo, HBO, and others are the providers and they send you the content you asked for. You run into issues when the content provider has problems providing the stream which is usually a blank screen for a few seconds. This is called buffering and happens for many reasons such as too many people streaming the same content and the provider does not have enough processing power, or servers to meet the demand. Small pipe sizes (not enough bandwidth from your ISP) and a number of other reasons.

Media Servers

The alternative is to play content locally. That is, the movies, pictures and music reside on a device in your home. How you get this content to your home varies (DVD to digital, bit torrents (illegal), purchasing digital media (legal).

The media server approach offers a number of advantages such as:

  • No buffering
  • You own the content
  • You can share your content
  • Easy to troubleshoot and fix

Now you have to decide what hardware and software you will use if you decide to move in this direction.  I have provided a brief comparison of the types of media servers available below. Most if not all the solutions you see for sale on the web fit into one of these catagories.

  Seagate Personal Cloud Raspberry PI2 Android PC Windows Media PC’s
Price 4TB  $199 $39 + 2+20+10 $99 $300-$500
OS Android Linux Android Windows
  Windows 10
Server Software Plex Server Rasplex Client Plex Client Plex Server
  Kodi Kodi Playon Media Server
 
Hardware

Processor

Marvell ARMADA 370 88F6707 A1 SoC @ 1.2 GHz

Cloud Drive won’t be able to transcode media for Plex in real-time, but that the device will be able to transcode in advance to have the media ready in the formats you’ll need.

A 900MHz quad-core ARM Cortex-A7 CPU

1GB RAM

Quad-core 1.6GHz CPU RK3188, Cortex-A9 (28nm) 2GB RAM Passmark score over 2500 (Intel i7).

Seagate Personal Cloud

The simplest way to go if you don’t want to make your home media system a hobby. The Seagate drive allows you to load a limited number of apps including my favorite media server Plex. With the Plex Roku channel and apps for Android and IOS, you are ready to go.

Pros: Simple to set up. Only one piece of hardware and not a lot of cables hanging around.

Cons: Users are having a difficult time getting the Plex app to work on the Seagate. I have gone to both the Seagate and the Plex forums.

Raspberry PI2

A popular linux box that has hundreds of uses (google it). There are a number of media server apps that can run on this platform. The best news is that a free copy of Windows 10 can run on this device.

Pros: A real linux PC the size of a deck of cards with all the connections you will ever need. Windows 10.

Cons: Limited RAM.

Android PC

There are a ton of android PC’s out there; and they are sometimes labeled as gaming consoles. They are inexpensive, small and can provide what you need to run a media server successfully. You can also run one of the best media servers out there called Kodi. TVADDONS offers a pre-packed version of Kodi for free that is very simple to install.

Pros: Small, inexpensive, will suit most folks who stream content and have a limited budget.

Cons: There is one drawback when you want to watch movies. Remember, transcoding is not supported for ARM and PPC models. Transcoding is a big deal when you watch movies. Click here to read what the Plex Server page says about transcoding (converting movie formats on the fly).

Windows Media PC’s

In my opinion the most expensive and high maintenance way to go. But if you are into high end video and want the best quality results on your TV, then spending the money for a custom built Windows PC is the way to go. You can use older PC’s to start with and when you have everything running right throughout the house, perform the upgrades you need to max out the performance.

Pros: Most people have or use a Windows PC. You probably have an older one sitting around you can start with. There are companies who make small footprint PC’s like Zotac (http://www.zotac.com).

Cons: There are always upgrades and the required reboots by the app creator or from Microsoft, so you will have to login and perform these functions to keep things running smoothly. Other systems do not require this step.

Homemediaguy

Click on the “Follow” button on my blog to be notified of future blog posts.

Check out my Youtube channel at Youtube: http://bit.ly/1xXdbUd

Non-tangible considerations when you want to dump cable TV March 2015

I just posted a great Cord Cutting calculator published by theverge.com that shows you what channels you can get from each provider and the cost for each. One thing they did not include is the non-tangible factors that play a BIG part on who you select.

There are really only three considerations you need to take into account when deciding to cut cable. They are:

  • Do I want live streaming TV?
  • Do I want DVR (ON Demand)?
  • How easy is it to surf channels (which we all do frequently)?
  • Buffering (it happens to everybody – Why?)?

The DVR capability in the IPTV world translates to ON-DEMAND when you look for it on the web. Almost all video on web pages (live cnn.com is the exception) is on demand. Julu, HuluPlus, Snagfilms and all movie web sites are also on demand. That is great if you never have the time to chill out on the couch for an afternoon to bum out and watch TV. But if you do want to surf the channels with no particular type of content in mind; you are out of luck unless you get an HD over the air antenna and grab free Live HD programming from your local stations. Just like your parents and grandparents did years ago.

I have put together a simple chart to get you started on how you want to migrate from cable TV below.

Source Live TV View Later (DVR) Channel Surfing Comment
Cable TV Yes DVR Easy
Over the Air Antenna (OTA) Yes Tablo.tv device Easy
Roku Box No Yes Hard On demand only viewing
Web sites (Casting from device) Maybe1 Yes Hard On demand only viewing

Almost all web sites do NOT have live streaming but a limited number of sites broadcast live such as CNN.com. When you watch a show like “Scandal“, notice the web page address. Each episode has a different web page address so you cannot just lock that web page into a ”favorite” using apps such as Plexit, PlayLater, etc. You have to go to the web page with the latest episode and mark it each time. Not really user friendly.

Homemediaguy

Click on the “Follow” button on my blog to be notified of future blog posts.

Check out my Youtube channel at Youtube: http://bit.ly/1xXdbUd

The Verge has a Cord Cutting calculator FREE!

Theverge.com has a Cord cutting calculator they published this week (http://www.theverge.com/a/online-tv-stream-price-guide) that lets you see what channels you get and how much their respective services cost. It’s real handy to determine which provider CBS all access, HBO Now, Netflix, Amazon, Hulu Plus, Sling TV and PlayStation Vue) gives you what you really want to watch. I have included screen shots below.

Blog Amazon Services w Price 031915 Blog CBS Services w Price 031915 Blog HBO Now Services w Price 031915 Blog Hulu Plus Services w Price 031915 Blog Netflix Services w Price 031915 Blog Playstation Vue Services w Price 031915

Homemediaguy

Click on the “Follow” button on my blog to be notified of future blog posts.

Check out my Youtube channel at Youtube: http://bit.ly/1xXdbUd